Recent job

But if water is getting under shingles, Im not gonna like it anyway.

I've said that many times, thinking it would be the end of the discussion/debate. I&W can fix everything right??

Chuck: We have a 20 year old 2/12 w/ 3-tabs on 4" exp, no extra sealants. Would I say it was OK or do it again? Heck no. I feel like it was luck. Plus shingles were $30/sq and labor was much cheaper.

They are usually ok clover until they develop unlevel spots in the decking or too much water empties out into one spot. Put shingles on a 2/12 with even a slightly unlevel deck and it may leak right away.